|
News for the Pews |
Home
31st October 2024
ThursdayReflection
************************
'Denny Burk shares'
'comment on everything I find interesting'
"What does it mean to
"act like a man" "
'in 1 Corinthians 16:13?'
************************
I've been preaching through 1 Corinthians at our church for the last couple years, and in my most recent message we came to a little phrase in 1 Corinthians 16:13 that has become a stumbling block for some readers.
The underlying Greek verb (andrizesthei) is rendered variously as "act like men" or "be courageous".
Some of those who favour "act like men" understand the text as a call to manhood.
Others dismiss that interpretation by noting that the command is addressed to both men and women.
For my part, I think either translation is fine.
Both of them are actually capturing something true about the original expression.
The Greek word in question is built on a root that refers to adult males.
That means that there are at least two semantic oppositions here, not one - male as opposed to female and adult as opposed to child.
The term's actual usage, however, reflects the connection between manliness and courage.
This particular usage means roughly the same thing we mean when we say "be a man" or "man up."
It calls for readers to put away whatever inhibitions or fears they might have about doing something, and do it.
It means "to faithfully carry out one's responsibilities even in the face of extreme danger and frightening circumstances."
Perhaps the best way to illustrate the usage is with a similar one in English.
Imagine standing on the high dive at the public swimming pool.
You walk slowly out to the edge, and when you see how far down it is, your stomach catches up in your throat.
You're staring down trying to figure out whether you are actually going to go through with the long drop, and you're taking so long that the line of people behind you is getting impatient, and someone yells, "C'mon, man up!"
They see your apprehension and fear, and they are telling you to get over it and get on with it.
And so what do you do? You man up, and you jump.
Likewise, the expression in 1 Corinthians 16:13 calls for courage.
That is why the NIV, NRSV, and others do well to render it as "be courageous."
That is a faithful interpretation.
It calls us to put aside whatever fears we have about the conflict we face for following Jesus, and to get on with it.
In this sense, courage is not the absence of fear.
Courage is the ability to overcome fear and apprehension because you 'fear' God more than you fear man.
We all understand that following Jesus is sometimes going to be hard.
It is sometimes going to be scary.
But what pushes us forward is not that we don't find things to be scary but that we love and trust Jesus even more than our fears.
But the call to courage is not the only thing going on with this term.
The author, the apostle Paul, has clearly chosen to use a stereotype that associates courage with masculinity.
Why would Paul speak like that?
Is he trying to say that men are supposed to be courageous but women aren't?
Of course not!
This command is given to everyone in the congregation, both men and women.
The call to courage is limited to neither male nor female but is required of both.
Nevertheless, the expression itself is a reflection of the way God designs men and women in their physical differences - that men are generally stronger than women and more mature than boys.
These characteristics make men fit for feats of courage and bravery.
Of course, not all men have great strength, but that is not the point.
This is a command to the whole church - men and women - but it is telling that Paul associates strength and courage with masculinity, a perspective embraced throughout Scripture."
The bottom line is that we have an apostle using a stereotypical expression that would not be received well were it uttered in our own culture today.
Last summer, BBC News published an article noting that the phrase "man up" means to "demonstrate toughness or courage when faced with a difficult situation."
Nevertheless, the article went on to suggest that it is "sexist" to associate such qualities with men.
And yet this association is precisely what appears in 1 Corinthians 16:13.
It is no surprise, therefore, that modern readers might dislike Paul's expression as well.
The scripture is not afraid to speak stereotypically about the natural connection between masculine strength and courage.
Because of that, we must recognize something very fundamental about masculine virtue even as we recognize that the command to courage applies to all of us, both male and female followers of Christ.
><(((°>
This is an edited version.
The full article and Bible references are avaiable on request
'My name is Denny Burk,'
and I have been a Professor of Biblical Studies at Boyce College since 2008.
I also serve as an Associate Pastor at Kenwood Baptist Church and as President of CBMW.
I started this blog in 2005 as a place to comment on everything I find interesting.
Usually, that means I'm commenting on theology, politics, and culture.
But over the years, this space has gone way beyond those topics.
So it is a bit of a hodge-podge, but then again, so is life.
And God's revelation relates to all of it, and writing about that connection is what I am most interested in.
Contact the Rector
The Revd.
Nic.Edwards
The Rectory,
Church Lane,
BUGBROOKE,
Northampton,
NN7 3PB
Land Line: 01604 - 815496
(Can be accessed from the mobile device)
Mobile: .....
E-mail:
thebeneficeofbhkandr at gmail dot com
Contact the Benefice Office
Sunday School Rooms, Church Lane,
BUGBROOKE, Northampton, NN7 3PB
Land Line: 01604 830373
E-mail:
thebeneficeofbhkandr at gmail dot com
Mon., Tues., Wed,, Thur., Fri.
9:00am to 11:30am
For Baptism bookings (Christenings)
to arrange an appointment please contact
the Benefice Office.
For Wedding bookings:
please contact the Benefice Office to arrange
an appointment.
Who Made This?
Seeing as you asked, if you can give helpful
advice or report factual corrections and
'deliberate mistakes',email:-
regparker3 at gmail dot com
Email addresses shown using words in an
attempt to avoid 'spam',
Type the email address replacing 'at' with '@',
and 'dot' with '.'
|